Does Twitter improve workplace productivity, or on balance does it distract employees and detract from their overall performance?
Globe and Mail writer Tavia Grant wrote about this very subject this week. Here’s a summary of the pros and cons of Twitter from her article:
The proponents
Jen Evans, president of Toronto-based Sequentia Communications, has 1,649 followers and tracks the musings of 1,283 others. She is a huge Twitter fan – for herself and her staff of 16.
Her business involves connecting businesses with clients, and she’s found Twitter invaluable for recruiting, drumming up business and building her brand.
Having staff on Twitter can be a “visibility enhancer,” she says.
Larger companies, too, are jumping on board.
Telus Corp. allows Twitter time at work. “You have to trust employees,” says spokesman Shawn Hall, who personally uses it “all the time” to stay connected to journalists, public relations groups and the telecommunications community.
The opponents
Employers are still wrestling with policies on Facebook and other more established social networking sites, never mind Twitter. But some, including several government departments, such as those for the City of Toronto, ban personal use at work.
Murray Key, operations manager of a steel warehousing company in Edmonton, can’t stand to see staff whittle away their work hours on any kind of social networking.
“There is a time and place to be a social butterfly, to play inane games and to waste personal time, but for the vast majority of us, that place is not at work,” he says.
Experiment with it
…Twitter has emerged as a “powerful tool that can speed up the metabolism of an organization, keep everyone better informed and enable greater agility and responsiveness to changing conditions.” [says Don Tapscott].
He encourages people to experiment with it. Managers should try it out – at least to understand how it works – and give employees a chance “to self-organize and collaborate using these tools,” he says.
Given Richard’s announcements that he’s now tweeting on Twitter, I thought I’d ask the CreativeClass.com audience for their thoughts.
So, to Twitter or not to Twitter?


March 3rd, 2009 at 10:26 am
Twitter can be helpful in making new contacts and finding solutions to problems but it can also just be a waste of time. So with any new tool a balance needs to be found to make it effective and not a time waster.
March 3rd, 2009 at 7:47 pm
If the City of Toronto has banned Twitter, how is it that Mayor Miller tweets?
March 3rd, 2009 at 8:48 pm
I find twitter to be helpful in keeping me connected in real time to a currently small trusted community that is working on or knows about certain software tools I use. By tracking through twitter, I am always getting and sharing new ideas on using these tools.
March 4th, 2009 at 3:43 am
It is utterly bogus.
We have a tendency to fill our time in order to escape the mundane responsibilities of adult life: talking to other people, looking after children or elderly parents, paying attention to other people. By seeking status in now “connected” and “busy” we are, we merely lavish attention on a machine, rather than society – in short, “social networking” tools are anything but “social”.
The “connectedness” of twitter is a chimera. It is not connected to anything. So we keep bang up to date with comment and news – about nothing. And whilst spending time being “connected” to the virtual world, the real world crashes around us and we absolve ourselves of our responsibilities, and blame “the government”, or just “them”.
March 4th, 2009 at 8:03 am
Twitter is great for keeping up with any information source where immediacy is crucial. At the CBC, Twitter keeps us all up to the minute with breaking news and world events. Depending on who you are following, Twitter can be a great way to keep up with social trends, technological information and the useful dreck that washes up on our shores. In our business, broadcasting, Twitter can be invaluable. But if used purely as a social tool I can see the naysayers point of view. If you were to take away my Tweetdeck I’m sure I could get along without it but there are obvious enhancements to having it that edges Twitter over to the positive side of the argument for me.